Kerala High Court Quashes Flag-Insult Case Over Accidental Upside-Down Display

The Kerala High Court quashed criminal proceedings against a man photographed holding the Indian flag upside down during the Har Ghar Tiranga programme, holding that Section 2 of the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act requires intentional disrespect.

What happened

The Kerala High Court quashed criminal proceedings against a man photographed holding the Indian flag upside down during the Har Ghar Tiranga programme, holding that Section 2 of the Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act requires intentional disrespect. Justice A Badharudeen said an accidental or mistaken inversion without mens rea does not constitute the offence. The Court, however, rejected the argument that circulation in a private WhatsApp group necessarily falls outside public view, noting that such a group may contain several members. The prosecution failed because the material did not establish deliberate insult, not because digital sharing is automatically private.

Legal significance

Holdings, observations, allegations and submissions are kept distinct. The legal effect is confined to the present development.

Practical consequence

Further consequences follow through the operative judicial, administrative or constitutional process described above.

Source: Read source report